Back to overview
  • Reduce Return Rate

Product reviews in online shops: an effective tool to support purchasing decisions

  • Published July 18, 2022
  • Sarah Birk
  • Reading time: 10 min.

When shopping online, customers cannot examine the goods with their own eyes or check their quality by touching them. They therefore have to rely on product photos and descriptions provided by the sellers. Product reviews help your buyers to find out whether the product in question meets their expectations. Below, you will learn how product reviews can help you optimize your online store and reduce your return rate.

A person is holding a smartphone in their hand, displaying several product reviews.

This is what is meant by a product review

Anyone who has ever ordered something from an online shop has probably encountered them: product or customer reviews. This type of customer feedback, also known as reviews, evaluates goods or services, usually in written form.

Origin of product evaluation

User criticism originated in newspapers and magazines, where films, plays, or books, for example, are reviewed. However, since the invention of the internet, reviews of social or cultural events or products are no longer reserved for journalists or professional critics— all users can express their personal opinions on any topic at any time in the comments section of websites.

This also applies to purchases made in online shops, where customers can share their experiences of the products or services they have purchased there with other shop visitors. Whether in text form or supplemented by the awarding of points or stars, customer reviews are an important factor in the purchasing decisions of potential buyers. For this reason, most shop operators ask their customers to rate their experiences with the purchase, product, or service after completing the transaction.


Stay up to date on personalization: Sign up for the epoq newsletter. Register now!


Product reviews are used here

Whether it's a restaurant, online supermarket, or moving company, customer reviews can be found wherever consumers purchase services or goods. According to a Capterra user study, 80% of consumers said they read customer reviews on Amazon in 2020.¹ So there are good reasons to integrate product reviews into your online shop to turn prospects into buyers – and thus increase sales.

Customer reviews are displayed in the online shop at notebooksbilliger.de.

notebooksbilliger.de offers customers the opportunity to rate products in the form of stars and text on the product detail page. (Source: Screenshot from notebooksbilliger.de)

Product reviews have numerous advantages for e-commerce

We have summarized below why product reviews are so useful in online shops:

Product reviews build trust and influence purchasing decisions

People like to base their decisions on what others think is good – and allow themselves to be influenced by this when making decisions. This phenomenon, known as social proof, also applies to e-commerce. For most German online shoppers, product reviews from other buyers are one of the most important factors influencing their purchasing decisions. According to a 2021 study by Bitkom, 54% of shoppers base their decisions on product reviews in online shops, while 44% rely on manufacturers' and retailers' websites, which include product descriptions, as a slightly less popular source of information.²

Reviews provide advice and prevent returns

There are now many different tools available to provide your customers with comprehensive advice online. Customer reviews in your online shop can also be seen as a form of advice. This decision-making aid works as a combination of product reviews by buyers and responses from shop operators. In your response to a review, you can, for example, provide important help and advice regarding returns or suggest alternative products that better meet the customer's expectations.

But buyer reviews alone can also provide advice. For example, when customers leave feedback that a garment runs particularly large or small, potential new customers can factor this information into their purchasing decision. Items with reviews are therefore purchased more often than those without reviews – and, above all, in the best case scenario, they are returned less often, thus avoiding returns. The more comprehensive the information your shop visitors can obtain about a product before purchasing it, the more likely you are to meet their expectations. By integrating product reviews into your online shop, you can reduce your return rate.

User feedback provides opportunities for optimizing the product range

Another advantage of product reviews is that they help you optimize your product range. Feedback from shoppers tells you which items you should keep in your range and how you could potentially expand it. Product reviews also ensure that product pages are constantly revitalized. The combination of static product descriptions and dynamic user content gives your customers the opportunity to find out everything they need to know about the product they want. In addition, Google ads with a high number of review stars bring more traffic to your shop.

Whether positive or negative, every product review counts.

It's not just high, positive star ratings that can help you optimize your online store and increase sales. Negative reviews and constructive criticism in particular show you why your customers may not be satisfied and what you can improve about your offering —with minimal effort. It is important to respond quickly, friendly, and objectively to any kind of criticism in order to maintain contact with the customer. Also keep an eye on product reviews that are posted outside your online shop, for example on comparison portals or in online communities.

Product reviews in online shops – these are the options available

Optimizing your online store based on product reviews can be done using an internal review system or third-party review tools. An internal system may seem like the simpler and cheaper option at first, as you don't have to pay an external service provider and you retain control over what is displayed on your online store's product pages at all times.

However, this apparent advantage can also backfire, because if your customers suspect that you, as the shop operator, are censoring product reviews in your favor and only allowing positive reviews, they will no longer trust your company. In order to survive alongside the broad competition in e-commerce, it is therefore advisable to equip your shop with third-party rating systems and thus convey maximum transparency and neutrality to your customers.

The right product rating system for your shop

There are a variety of providers in the field of product reviews on the internet. Since customer reviews can lead to a lower return rate and thus increase your sales, choosing the right system for your shop is crucial. The ideal product review system is clear, easy to understand (e.g., by awarding stars), and inspires confidence. It is worth relying on providers who have established themselves on the basis of their reliability and expertise. The product rating systems of the following companies are particularly widely used:

  • Trusted Shops
  • eTrusted
  • Trustpilot
  • Google

An important criterion for gaining the trust of your shop visitors with regard to product reviews is the transaction-based rating system. Here, only customers who actually purchase a product in your online shop can rate it afterwards. To do so, they must be logged in via a user account and write their reviews under their name, meaning they cannot remain anonymous. However, this virtually eliminates misuse of the rating function and significantly increases the credibility of the reviews for your products.

Reviews for the entire online store

In addition to evaluating individual products, consumers can also rate entire stores. Criteria can include customer service, delivery speed, or product range. Ideally, you can integrate positive store ratings into your online store in the form of badges. Well-known examples of store ratings are:

  • Trustpilot
  • buyer seal
  • Ekomi
  • Veristore
Excerpt from the NKD online shop showing a shop rating from Trusted Shops.

NKD has integrated a Trusted Shops badge into its shop, which allows customers to view the rating score, among other things. (Source: Screenshot from nkd.com)

Additional consulting services to supplement product evaluations

In order to make the digital customer journey as satisfying as possible, online retailers are constantly looking for ways to make their customer service as similar as possible to that offered in brick-and-mortar stores. In addition to reliable product descriptions, the product detail page offers you the opportunity to give your customers that decisive impulse to buy. This is because, ideally, this is where they can find out everything they want to know about their desired product. An informative and clearly structured product detail page is a good substitute for the shopping experience in a brick-and-mortar store and thus increases your conversion rate.


Stay up to date on personalization: Sign up for the epoq newsletter. Register now!


You can also optimize the consulting process for your customers with an intuitive online product advisorin the form of an AI shopping assistant, which supports them in selecting products and guides them to the right product through interactive dialogue. It accurately identifies their needs and filters out the appropriate items from your range. It combines current product data with click and purchase behavior to make recommendations even more accurate and personalized. This dialogue-based consultation reduces the return rate and helps customers make informed purchasing decisions.

Example of a wine shop with an AI shopping assistant that displays helpful tags such as "dry" or "semi-dry" in addition to matching results for the query "I'm looking for a white wine from Germany."

The AI Shopping Assistant offers customers an additional source of advice, helping them to make purchasing decisions.
(Source: Own representation)

Conclusion: Product reviews help customers make the right purchasing decision.

By integrating product reviews into your online shop, you offer an additional advisory element that enables your customers to select the product they want based on their own requirements and expectations. If you want to use an external review system for this purpose, you should pay attention to the expertise of the third-party providers. In combination with other digital advisory tools, you can ultimately reduce the return rate and increase customer satisfaction at the same time.

Source: ¹ Capterra, ² Bitkom

Frequently asked questions about product reviews in the online store

Would you like to learn more about digital consulting in e-commerce?

Check out our publication on the topic!

Sarah, Junior Content Marketing Manager at epoq
Sarah Birk
Online Marketing Manager - Content & SEO
Sarah works as Online Marketing Manager – Content & SEO at Epoq and is responsible for the content area. Her responsibilities range from content planning and conception to analysis and optimization of various content formats, taking important SEO aspects into account.